How To Approach A Difficult Commercial Conversation

How To Approach A Difficult Commercial Conversation

Whether you’re defending a final account, chasing an under-valued application or telling a client their budget won’t stretch, difficult conversations are part of a Quantity Surveyors role. Handle them well and you protect both the money and the relationship. Here are some tips on how to approach them.

Prepare more than you think you need to

Most difficult conversations are won or lost before you walk into the room. Know the facts inside out: the contract position, the notices that have been served, the dates, the figures, and the records that back them up. If you’re relying on a clause, have it to hand. Confidence comes from preparation, and the other side can tell when you haven’t done it.

Know what you want, and where your limit is

Before the meeting, be clear on three things:

Metroun LearningShort courses with structured CPD, 20 minutes eachStart ›
  • your ideal outcome
  • the outcome you could realistically accept
  • your walk-away point, and what you’ll do if you reach it (adjudication, escalation, or simply parking the issue)

If you go in without a limit, you’ll end up negotiating against yourself.

Understand their position

Put yourself in the other person’s shoes. What pressure are they under? A client Quantity Surveyor might be up against a fixed budget or a board approval. A subcontractor might have a cash-flow problem. When you understand what’s driving them, you can find solutions that work for both sides rather than arguing about a single number.

Choose the right setting

Difficult conversations rarely go well over email. Tone gets misread and positions harden. Where you can, pick up the phone or meet in person, and choose a time when neither of you is rushed. If the discussion is about settling a dispute, agree at the start whether it’s being held on a ‘without prejudice basis’.

Separate the people from the problem

Stay calm, professional and factual. Talk about the issue, not the individual. Phrases like “this is how we’ve arrived at our figure” go much further than “your assessment is wrong.” And remember, you may be working with these people again on the next project.

Listen properly

Let the other side make their case in full. Ask questions and repeat their key points back to them. You’ll often find the gap is smaller than it looked, or that the disagreement is about one specific item rather than the whole account. Listening also earns you the right to be heard.

Trade, don’t concede

If you give something, get something back. Look for packages rather than going line by line: agreeing a group of variations together, for example, or trading on programme, payment timing or the release of retention. Avoid splitting the difference just to end an awkward moment.

Confirm it in writing

As soon as the conversation is over, follow it up in writing with what was agreed, the next steps and who owns them. A verbal agreement that isn’t recorded can quickly turn into a new dispute.

Difficult conversations don’t have to be confrontational. With good preparation, a clear objective and some empathy, they’re often where the best commercial outcomes come from.

Metroun Learning

62 QS courses, ready when you are

  • Structured CPD, logged as you go
  • 20 minutes of CPD per course, with a certificate
  • NEC, JCT, FIDIC, QS basics and more

£199.99 a year, or £49.99 a month

Start learning ›

Other ways we can help

QS consultancyNeed a QS?Experienced QSs for valuations, variations and final accounts.Talk to a QS ›APC candidatesGoing for MRICS?Your own MRICS counsellor, two one hour sessions a month. £399.99 a month.Apply now ›

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to receive all the latest updates.

More articles for you